Boult Wade Tennant
TPU » UK confirms non-participation in the Unified Patent Court

It was recently announced that the UK has notified the European Council that it has withdrawn its ratification of the Unified Patent Court Agreement.

This move will not come as a surprise, since the UK Government had already indicated its intent earlier in this year. Nevertheless, this is still a disappointing development in an already fraught ongoing process.

What does the withdrawal mean for the UK’s role in the UPC?
As many will know, the Unified Patent Court (UPC) project includes new legislation that would set up new patent courts across participating EU member states. These courts would be competent to hear litigation and revocation disputes relating to European patents granted by the European Patent Office (EPO). The project is closely tied to the European Union, with the agreed legislation requiring participants to be member states of the European Union.

However, the inclusion of so-called “third countries” in the project was not envisioned, so the outcome of the 2016 Brexit referendum cast doubt on the continued involvement of the UK in the UPC. Despite this, there were hopes that the UK may still be able to participate, given the UK’s significant role in the existing European patent system. These hopes were previously shared by the UK Government, with the ratification of the UPC agreement by the UK in 2018. While the language of the existing UPC legislation complicated the practicalities of continued UK involvement (which would involve at the very least a redrafting of that legislation), it was clear that participation was possible as long as there was the political will on both sides.

Unfortunately, the recent announcement has confirmed that this political will is no longer present, at least on the side of the UK Government. By withdrawing its ratification, the door has been firmly closed on the UK’s involvement in the UPC.

What does the withdrawal mean for the UPC at large?
The withdrawal of the UK’s UPC ratification, while disappointing, does not damage the larger UPC project beyond repair, and there is hope that it can still survive. The existing UPC legislation does assume that the UK would be a participating member (for example, the legislation explicitly identifies London as a location for the Central Division of the UPC), but legislation can be changed with the agreement of participating members. From a purely legal perspective, therefore, it is still possible for the UPC to continue in spite of the UK’s announcement.

The question of its continuation is, instead, a political one. Without the UK, the UPC could be viewed by member states as a very different system from the one envisioned in the current legislation. In particular, member states may reconsider the financial obligations in view of changed economic benefits of the UPC without the UK, and they may have diverging opinions on which country should now be host to the Central Division previously slated for London. Furthermore, some member countries may wish to revisit those elements of the UPC legal procedure that were negotiated based on input from UK legal experts and in view of UK law.

There is also a concern that without the participation of the UK, the UPC may be a less attractive system for applicants, since the UK is currently one of the three most popular countries for validation of European patents under the existing system (alongside France and Germany).

These issues and others may have significant impact on how other member states may view their relationship with the UPC going forward. There is also the matter of Germany, where the ratification of the UPC must again be considered by the German legislature following a successful constitutional challenge.

The reactions to this development by the remaining participants of the UPC and other involved parties will be of great interest. In particular, the UPC preparatory committee has stated that it intends to convene “to discuss the consequences of the UK withdrawal and agree a way forward”.

No effect on UK’s involvement with European Patent Office
We can continue to reassure applicants and patentees that the United Kingdom remains an enthusiastic member of the European Patent Convention, and the decision of the UK Government to withdraw its ratification of the UPC will not prevent applicants from obtaining patent protection in the UK by means of European patents at the European Patent Office (EPO).

Relevant sectors
Aeroespacial
  • Aeronáutica y vehículos aéreos no tripulados, tecnología espacial y satélites
  • Automoción, vehículos autónomos y eléctricos
  • Aviación comercial
  • Defensa y seguridad
  • Espacio y satélites
  • Sistemas de propulsión
  • Sistemas de suspensión
  • Transporte y logística
  • Unmanned aerial vehicles
  • Vehículos aéreos no tripulados
Alimentación y bebidas
  • Bebidas
  • Nutrición
Automoción
  • Energy and green technologies
  • Motores
  • Vehículos autónomos
  • Vehículos eléctricos
Bienes de consumo y comercio minorista
  • Alimentación y bebidas
  • Artículos de lujo
  • Belleza
  • Dispositivos antifalsificación
  • moda
  • Muebles y electrodomésticos
  • Salud, forma física y deporte
  • Venta al por menor
Biotecnología
  • Administración de fármacos
  • Anticuerpos terapéuticos
  • Bioinformática
  • Biología sintética
  • Biosimilares
  • Certificados complementarios de protección (CCP)
  • Cultivos transgénicos
  • Edición de genes (por ejemplo, CRISPR)
  • Fabricación y formulación de anticuerpos
  • GM crops
  • Herramientas y métodos genómicos y moleculares
  • Ingeniería de anticuerpos
  • Inmuno-oncología (inhibidores de puntos de control; linfocitos T modificados...)
  • Medicina personalizada/Biomarcadores de enfermedad
  • Producción y purificación de proteínas recombinantes
  • Productos para la salud de la mujer
  • Secuenciación de nueva generación
  • Síntesis de ácidos nucleicos
  • Terapias con células madre
  • Vacunología (vectores virales; vacunas de ARNm...)
Electrónica y dispositivos eléctricos
  • Arquitectura informática y diseño de sistemas
  • Computer and IT architecture and system design
  • control systems
  • Dispositivos semiconductores
  • Instrumentos científicos
  • Medical devices
  • Óptica
  • Productos sanitarios
  • Restaurants and bars
  • Robótica
  • Sistemas de ensayo, sistemas de control, procesamiento de señales
  • Tecnología vestible e interfaces humanas
  • Travel and leisure
  • Viajes y ocio
  • Wearable tech and human interfaces
Energía verde y energías renovables
  • Aerogeneradores
  • Agua, petróleo y gas, nuclear, fusión, fisión
  • Aire limpio
  • Biocarburantes
  • Energía solar
  • Fuel cells and battery technology
  • Renovables y reciclado
  • Tecnología de pilas de combustible y baterías
Fabricación y transformación industrial
  • Administración de fármacos
  • Certificados complementarios de protección (CCP)
  • Diagnóstico
  • Entrada en el mercado de los genéricos
  • Formulaciones farmacéuticas
  • Medicina personalizada/Biomarcadores de enfermedad
  • Métodos de producción y síntesis
  • Personalised medicine/Disease biomarkers
  • Pharmaceuticalsceutical formulations
  • Polimorfos
  • Productos farmacéuticos basados en moléculas pequeñas
  • Química médica
Fabricación y transformación industrial
  • Construcción
  • Embalaje
  • Fabricación aditiva
  • Polímeros y plásticos
  • Printing tech
  • Revestimientos
  • Tecnología de impresión
Informática y software
  • Aplicaciones y sistemas informáticos, aplicaciones móviles, interfaces de usuario
  • Asistentes digitales, asistentes virtuales y agentes
  • Asistentes digitales, asistentes virtuales y agentes
  • audio/video processing and animation
  • Automatización robótica de procesos
  • Bioinformática
  • Blockchain y tecnología de contabilidad distribuida (DLT)
  • Captación de motores
  • Captura de movimiento
  • Comunicaciones y redes
  • FinTech y AdTech
  • Gestión y almacenamiento de datos, bases de datos y compresión de datos
  • Informática cuántica
  • Inteligencia artificial y aprendizaje automático
  • Juegos de ordenador
  • Metaverso, realidad virtual (RV) y realidad aumentada (RA)
  • mobile applications
  • Motores de búsqueda
  • Multimedia, tratamiento de audio/vídeo y animación
  • Procesamiento del lenguaje natural
  • Seguridad de datos y programas informáticos, criptografía y gestión de derechos digitales (DRM)
  • Tratamiento de señales
  • Visión artificial
Inteligencia artificial y aprendizaje automático
Marcas
  • Bienes de consumo y comercio minorista (retail)
  • Cosmética y perfumería
  • Financial services
  • Ingeniería mecánica
  • Productos mecánicos
  • Servicios
  • Telecommunications
Materiales
  • Materiales avanzados
  • Materiales compuestos
  • Metalurgia y aleaciones
  • Nanotecnología
Productos médicos y de diagnóstico
  • Administración de fármacos
  • Diagnóstico in vitro
  • Dispositivos
  • Immuno-oncology
  • Instrumentos de diagnóstico
  • Inteligencia artificial
  • Medtech
  • Productos sanitarios y sistemas de suministro
  • Salud digital
  • Tecnología médica
Productos químicos
  • Agroquímicos
  • Catalizadores
  • Dispersiones y coloides
  • Lubricantes
  • Polímeros y plásticos
Telecomunicaciones y redes
  • Computación en nube
  • Internet de las cosas (IoT)
  • Oceanografía marina
  • Redes cableadas e inalámbricas